Roof shingles vs. Cedar shakes
Bob Harvey Roofing • June 14, 2022
A quality roof serves a dual purpose. On the one hand, it protects the occupants and contents of a home against the elements. On the other, a beautiful roof greatly enhances the appearance of a building and boosts its resale value. Both cedar and asphalt can achieve these goals, so what is the difference between the two. Here is a brief guide to help you decide between roof shingles vs. cedar shakes.
The Difference Between Asphalt Shingles & Cedar Shakes
To start with, and to state the obvious, shingles and cedar shakes are made of very different materials and thus have different sets of attributes. Cedar shakes are cut from real cedar wood, while shingles are made from asphalt, fiberglass and other materials. Asphalt shingles give a roof a smooth, sleek appearance, while shakes provide a rough, rugged, “woodsy” appeal.
Cedar Shake Roof vs. Asphalt Shingles Cost
Generally speaking, cedar shakes are significantly more expensive than asphalt shingles. If you want a natural, all-wood roof, you can opt for cedar shakes, but you will need to pay a premium for doing so. After weighing up the pros and cons, you may decide the extra expense is worthwhile. It depends on your budget and the look you have in mind. On average, a cedar shakes roof could cost anywhere between $8.00 and $15.00 per square foot. A shingle roof is much cheaper - between $3.50 and $5.50.
Pros and Cons of Cedar Shakes vs. Asphalt Shingles
Aside from the costs, there are several other factors you should consider as you try to decide between cedar shakes and asphalt shingles. Let’s take a look at the major pros and cons.
Asphalt Shingles
Shingles have become the market standard for a reason: they have most of the properties that homeowners and builders look for. These include:
- They are durable and have a good life expectancy
- You can choose from a wide range of colors and patterns
- They are suitable for DIY installation
- They are affordable
- They are energy efficient
- They can be installed on most roofs and are extremely versatile
- You can purchase shingles that have very wind ratings if that is what you require
On the other hand, there are some cons:
- Shingles are not as durable as some other roofing options
- They need a lot of maintenance to prevent breaking and mildew growth
- They can crack, which leads to leaks and further damage inside the home
- They are not as effective in cold climates
- They are not as elegant in appearance as shakes and other roofing materials
Cedar Shakes
Cedar shakes offer the following benefits:
- They provide classic style and universal appeal
- They can last up to 30 years
- They are resistant to insects
- They offer excellent protection against wind and impact
- They provide better airflow
- They boost your home’s appearance and value
- They are extremely efficient insulators
Here are some cons to think about:
- Being made of wood, they are susceptible to fire. They can be treated to make them fire-resistant, but that increase the cost of installation.
- They retain moisture and will need to be cleaned of moss and fungi every few years
- They must be installed by a professional and are not a good option for DIY
Bob Harvey Roofing is a professional roofing company in Layton, UT. We have been providing excellent service throughout northern Utah for the past 30 years. We are happy to talk you through the pros and cons of roofing, and we install and repair all roofing types.Contact us for more information about your roofing options, especially if you are considering the relative merits of roof shingles vs. cedar shakes.
Ask About a Free Estimate
Show More
Introduction Utah homeowners know that the state’s weather doesn’t play fair—scorching summers, heavy snowfall, sudden spring downpours. But what many don’t realize is how all that weather quietly takes a toll on one crucial system: your roof drainage. And when that system fails? It’s not just about clogged gutters—it’s about thousands of dollars in hidden damage to your roof, walls, foundation, and even your health. Roof drainage problems in Utah are more common than you might think, especially in older homes or those with flat or low-slope roofs. From standing water that rots decking and forms ice dams, to overflowing gutters that erode your landscaping and crack your foundation, poor drainage can destroy your home from the top down. In this article, we’ll break down the signs of drainage failure, the specific risks Utah homes face, and how to protect your biggest investment. You’ll learn what causes drainage issues, how to spot early warning signs, and the smart, affordable upgrades that can save you from costly repairs. What Is Roof Drainage? And Why Utah Homes Need It Working Right When most Utah homeowners think about roof maintenance, they picture shingles, flashing, or maybe even attic insulation. But one of the most overlooked systems—yet arguably one of the most critical—is your roof drainage. Without it, all the snowmelt, rain, and runoff from Utah’s wild weather has nowhere to go… except into your home’s structure. A roof drainage system is designed to move water efficiently off the roof and away from your home. It includes: - Gutters and downspouts - Roof pitch or slope - Flashing and drip edges - Downspout extensions or underground drainage pipes The goal is to prevent water from pooling on your roof, running behind siding, or collecting around your foundation. In Utah’s climate, that’s no small task. You’re dealing with ice dams in January, thunderstorms in July, and even snowstorms in April. Many older homes along the Wasatch Front—including Roy, Bountiful, and Ogden—were built with minimal or outdated drainage systems. If your home can’t shed water properly, you’re at serious risk of roof leaks, wood rot, and even structural damage. Quick Takeaways - Roof drainage problems in Utah are a leading cause of hidden home damage. - Signs include overflowing gutters, stained siding, and attic mold. - Common causes: clogged gutters, flat roofs, and poor attic ventilation. - Drainage issues can lead to foundation cracks, energy loss, and mold. - Preventative steps include gutter guards, downspout extensions, and insulation upgrades. - Bob Harvey Roofing provides expert inspections and drainage solutions across Utah. Conclusion Utah’s dramatic climate makes roof drainage a critical part of your home’s defense system. As we've explored, roof drainage problems in Utah can quietly lead to serious damage: rotting roof decking, mold in your attic, cracked foundations, and escalating energy bills. The good news? Most drainage issues are completely preventable. Whether it's cleaning your gutters, adjusting your downspouts, or upgrading insulation, small fixes can prevent big problems. At Bob Harvey Roofing, we know how to build and repair systems that handle Utah's extreme conditions—from ice dams to monsoons. We don’t just fix damage—we help you prevent it. Don’t wait until you see water stains. Book your roof drainage inspection today. FAQs 1. What causes roof drainage problems in Utah homes? Utah drainage issues often result from clogged gutters, poorly sloped roofs, or short downspouts. Snowmelt and monsoons can easily overwhelm these systems. 2. How do I know if my gutters are affecting my foundation? Look for water pooling near the base of your home, musty basements, or cracks in concrete walls. 3. Are ice dams a sign of roof drainage failure? Yes. Ice dams prevent water from flowing off your roof. This causes leaks, rot, and long-term damage. 4. Can poor roof drainage increase my energy bills? Absolutely. Moisture from drainage issues can ruin your insulation, forcing your HVAC system to work harder. 5. How often should I clean my gutters in Utah? At least twice a year—spring and fall. More often if you live near trees. 6. What are the best gutter options for Utah weather? Seamless gutters with guards are ideal for handling snow, rain, and debris. 7. Is roof drainage repair covered by homeowners insurance in Utah? It depends. Sudden damage is usually covered. Neglected maintenance is not. 8. When should I call a roofing contractor about drainage issues? Call if you see overflowing gutters, staining, or interior moisture. A professional inspection can catch problems early. References Better Homes & Gardens. How to Prevent and Remove Ice Dams from Your Roof. Utah Climate Center. Statewide Climate Data and Observations . U.S. EPA. What You Can Do to Soak Up the Rain. Wikipedia. Ice dam (roof). EPA. Low‑Impact Development & Green Infrastructure Practices. What Should You Do When Your Roof Begins to Leak? 10 Roof Problems and How to Spot Them Roof Inspections in Utah: What You Need to Know Roofing Guide: TPO vs PVC How Trees Can Damage Residential Roofing
Make Your Roy, Utah Roof Last Longer
Tar and Gravel roofs can last a long time with proper maintenance and care. Learn about how to extend the life of your roof.
This is a subtitle for your new post
Introduction to Green Roofing Is your roof over 15 years old or showing signs of storm damage? If so, it might be time to consider a greener option—both for your home and the environment. Green roofing is becoming a popular choice for Utah homeowners looking to upgrade their roofs sustainably. Not only can it improve your home’s energy efficiency, but it also provides environmental benefits like improved air quality, stormwater management, and enhanced local biodiversity. In this comprehensive guide, we’ll explore everything you need to know about green roofing in Utah . We'll cover how green roofs work, the best types for Utah’s dry summers and snowy winters, and how they can save you money in the long run. Whether you're curious about the cost of installation, maintenance requirements, or simply want to know if your home is a good candidate for a green roof, this article has you covered. By the end, you'll have a clear understanding of whether green roofing is the right choice for your home. Benefits of Green Roofing in Utah Energy Efficiency and Cost Savings One of the key advantages of green roofing for Utah homes is the energy savings it offers. During the hot summers, green roofs provide natural insulation, reducing the need for air conditioning. In fact, a properly installed green roof can lower cooling costs by up to 25% during Utah’s hottest months. In winter, the additional layer of vegetation acts as insulation , keeping heat inside and reducing energy consumption. Over time, these savings can add up, helping homeowners reduce utility costs while creating a more comfortable living environment.
In Utah, homes need regular maintenance. Some simple steps can protect your home and your investment.
Roof Repairs for your Garage
How Long Does it Take to Replace a Roof in Utah?
How Often Should you Replace your Roof?
How much does it typically cost to replace a roof in Utah?
Introduction Utah homeowners know that the state’s weather doesn’t play fair—scorching summers, heavy snowfall, sudden spring downpours. But what many don’t realize is how all that weather quietly takes a toll on one crucial system: your roof drainage. And when that system fails? It’s not just about clogged gutters—it’s about thousands of dollars in hidden damage to your roof, walls, foundation, and even your health. Roof drainage problems in Utah are more common than you might think, especially in older homes or those with flat or low-slope roofs. From standing water that rots decking and forms ice dams, to overflowing gutters that erode your landscaping and crack your foundation, poor drainage can destroy your home from the top down. In this article, we’ll break down the signs of drainage failure, the specific risks Utah homes face, and how to protect your biggest investment. You’ll learn what causes drainage issues, how to spot early warning signs, and the smart, affordable upgrades that can save you from costly repairs. What Is Roof Drainage? And Why Utah Homes Need It Working Right When most Utah homeowners think about roof maintenance, they picture shingles, flashing, or maybe even attic insulation. But one of the most overlooked systems—yet arguably one of the most critical—is your roof drainage. Without it, all the snowmelt, rain, and runoff from Utah’s wild weather has nowhere to go… except into your home’s structure. A roof drainage system is designed to move water efficiently off the roof and away from your home. It includes: - Gutters and downspouts - Roof pitch or slope - Flashing and drip edges - Downspout extensions or underground drainage pipes The goal is to prevent water from pooling on your roof, running behind siding, or collecting around your foundation. In Utah’s climate, that’s no small task. You’re dealing with ice dams in January, thunderstorms in July, and even snowstorms in April. Many older homes along the Wasatch Front—including Roy, Bountiful, and Ogden—were built with minimal or outdated drainage systems. If your home can’t shed water properly, you’re at serious risk of roof leaks, wood rot, and even structural damage. Quick Takeaways - Roof drainage problems in Utah are a leading cause of hidden home damage. - Signs include overflowing gutters, stained siding, and attic mold. - Common causes: clogged gutters, flat roofs, and poor attic ventilation. - Drainage issues can lead to foundation cracks, energy loss, and mold. - Preventative steps include gutter guards, downspout extensions, and insulation upgrades. - Bob Harvey Roofing provides expert inspections and drainage solutions across Utah. Conclusion Utah’s dramatic climate makes roof drainage a critical part of your home’s defense system. As we've explored, roof drainage problems in Utah can quietly lead to serious damage: rotting roof decking, mold in your attic, cracked foundations, and escalating energy bills. The good news? Most drainage issues are completely preventable. Whether it's cleaning your gutters, adjusting your downspouts, or upgrading insulation, small fixes can prevent big problems. At Bob Harvey Roofing, we know how to build and repair systems that handle Utah's extreme conditions—from ice dams to monsoons. We don’t just fix damage—we help you prevent it. Don’t wait until you see water stains. Book your roof drainage inspection today. FAQs 1. What causes roof drainage problems in Utah homes? Utah drainage issues often result from clogged gutters, poorly sloped roofs, or short downspouts. Snowmelt and monsoons can easily overwhelm these systems. 2. How do I know if my gutters are affecting my foundation? Look for water pooling near the base of your home, musty basements, or cracks in concrete walls. 3. Are ice dams a sign of roof drainage failure? Yes. Ice dams prevent water from flowing off your roof. This causes leaks, rot, and long-term damage. 4. Can poor roof drainage increase my energy bills? Absolutely. Moisture from drainage issues can ruin your insulation, forcing your HVAC system to work harder. 5. How often should I clean my gutters in Utah? At least twice a year—spring and fall. More often if you live near trees. 6. What are the best gutter options for Utah weather? Seamless gutters with guards are ideal for handling snow, rain, and debris. 7. Is roof drainage repair covered by homeowners insurance in Utah? It depends. Sudden damage is usually covered. Neglected maintenance is not. 8. When should I call a roofing contractor about drainage issues? Call if you see overflowing gutters, staining, or interior moisture. A professional inspection can catch problems early. References Better Homes & Gardens. How to Prevent and Remove Ice Dams from Your Roof. Utah Climate Center. Statewide Climate Data and Observations . U.S. EPA. What You Can Do to Soak Up the Rain. Wikipedia. Ice dam (roof). EPA. Low‑Impact Development & Green Infrastructure Practices. What Should You Do When Your Roof Begins to Leak? 10 Roof Problems and How to Spot Them Roof Inspections in Utah: What You Need to Know Roofing Guide: TPO vs PVC How Trees Can Damage Residential Roofing
Make Your Roy, Utah Roof Last Longer
Tar and Gravel roofs can last a long time with proper maintenance and care. Learn about how to extend the life of your roof.
Introduction Utah homeowners know that the state’s weather doesn’t play fair—scorching summers, heavy snowfall, sudden spring downpours. But what many don’t realize is how all that weather quietly takes a toll on one crucial system: your roof drainage. And when that system fails? It’s not just about clogged gutters—it’s about thousands of dollars in hidden damage to your roof, walls, foundation, and even your health. Roof drainage problems in Utah are more common than you might think, especially in older homes or those with flat or low-slope roofs. From standing water that rots decking and forms ice dams, to overflowing gutters that erode your landscaping and crack your foundation, poor drainage can destroy your home from the top down. In this article, we’ll break down the signs of drainage failure, the specific risks Utah homes face, and how to protect your biggest investment. You’ll learn what causes drainage issues, how to spot early warning signs, and the smart, affordable upgrades that can save you from costly repairs. What Is Roof Drainage? And Why Utah Homes Need It Working Right When most Utah homeowners think about roof maintenance, they picture shingles, flashing, or maybe even attic insulation. But one of the most overlooked systems—yet arguably one of the most critical—is your roof drainage. Without it, all the snowmelt, rain, and runoff from Utah’s wild weather has nowhere to go… except into your home’s structure. A roof drainage system is designed to move water efficiently off the roof and away from your home. It includes: - Gutters and downspouts - Roof pitch or slope - Flashing and drip edges - Downspout extensions or underground drainage pipes The goal is to prevent water from pooling on your roof, running behind siding, or collecting around your foundation. In Utah’s climate, that’s no small task. You’re dealing with ice dams in January, thunderstorms in July, and even snowstorms in April. Many older homes along the Wasatch Front—including Roy, Bountiful, and Ogden—were built with minimal or outdated drainage systems. If your home can’t shed water properly, you’re at serious risk of roof leaks, wood rot, and even structural damage. Quick Takeaways - Roof drainage problems in Utah are a leading cause of hidden home damage. - Signs include overflowing gutters, stained siding, and attic mold. - Common causes: clogged gutters, flat roofs, and poor attic ventilation. - Drainage issues can lead to foundation cracks, energy loss, and mold. - Preventative steps include gutter guards, downspout extensions, and insulation upgrades. - Bob Harvey Roofing provides expert inspections and drainage solutions across Utah. Conclusion Utah’s dramatic climate makes roof drainage a critical part of your home’s defense system. As we've explored, roof drainage problems in Utah can quietly lead to serious damage: rotting roof decking, mold in your attic, cracked foundations, and escalating energy bills. The good news? Most drainage issues are completely preventable. Whether it's cleaning your gutters, adjusting your downspouts, or upgrading insulation, small fixes can prevent big problems. At Bob Harvey Roofing, we know how to build and repair systems that handle Utah's extreme conditions—from ice dams to monsoons. We don’t just fix damage—we help you prevent it. Don’t wait until you see water stains. Book your roof drainage inspection today. FAQs 1. What causes roof drainage problems in Utah homes? Utah drainage issues often result from clogged gutters, poorly sloped roofs, or short downspouts. Snowmelt and monsoons can easily overwhelm these systems. 2. How do I know if my gutters are affecting my foundation? Look for water pooling near the base of your home, musty basements, or cracks in concrete walls. 3. Are ice dams a sign of roof drainage failure? Yes. Ice dams prevent water from flowing off your roof. This causes leaks, rot, and long-term damage. 4. Can poor roof drainage increase my energy bills? Absolutely. Moisture from drainage issues can ruin your insulation, forcing your HVAC system to work harder. 5. How often should I clean my gutters in Utah? At least twice a year—spring and fall. More often if you live near trees. 6. What are the best gutter options for Utah weather? Seamless gutters with guards are ideal for handling snow, rain, and debris. 7. Is roof drainage repair covered by homeowners insurance in Utah? It depends. Sudden damage is usually covered. Neglected maintenance is not. 8. When should I call a roofing contractor about drainage issues? Call if you see overflowing gutters, staining, or interior moisture. A professional inspection can catch problems early. References Better Homes & Gardens. How to Prevent and Remove Ice Dams from Your Roof. Utah Climate Center. Statewide Climate Data and Observations . U.S. EPA. What You Can Do to Soak Up the Rain. Wikipedia. Ice dam (roof). EPA. Low‑Impact Development & Green Infrastructure Practices. What Should You Do When Your Roof Begins to Leak? 10 Roof Problems and How to Spot Them Roof Inspections in Utah: What You Need to Know Roofing Guide: TPO vs PVC How Trees Can Damage Residential Roofing
Make Your Roy, Utah Roof Last Longer
Tar and Gravel roofs can last a long time with proper maintenance and care. Learn about how to extend the life of your roof.
This is a subtitle for your new post
Introduction to Green Roofing Is your roof over 15 years old or showing signs of storm damage? If so, it might be time to consider a greener option—both for your home and the environment. Green roofing is becoming a popular choice for Utah homeowners looking to upgrade their roofs sustainably. Not only can it improve your home’s energy efficiency, but it also provides environmental benefits like improved air quality, stormwater management, and enhanced local biodiversity. In this comprehensive guide, we’ll explore everything you need to know about green roofing in Utah . We'll cover how green roofs work, the best types for Utah’s dry summers and snowy winters, and how they can save you money in the long run. Whether you're curious about the cost of installation, maintenance requirements, or simply want to know if your home is a good candidate for a green roof, this article has you covered. By the end, you'll have a clear understanding of whether green roofing is the right choice for your home. Benefits of Green Roofing in Utah Energy Efficiency and Cost Savings One of the key advantages of green roofing for Utah homes is the energy savings it offers. During the hot summers, green roofs provide natural insulation, reducing the need for air conditioning. In fact, a properly installed green roof can lower cooling costs by up to 25% during Utah’s hottest months. In winter, the additional layer of vegetation acts as insulation , keeping heat inside and reducing energy consumption. Over time, these savings can add up, helping homeowners reduce utility costs while creating a more comfortable living environment.
In Utah, homes need regular maintenance. Some simple steps can protect your home and your investment.
Roof Repairs for your Garage
How Long Does it Take to Replace a Roof in Utah?
How Often Should you Replace your Roof?
How much does it typically cost to replace a roof in Utah?
