
Ultimate Tar and Gravel Roof Guide 2026
Bob Harvey Roofing • January 9, 2026
Tar and gravel roofs are everywhere in Utah—on older ramblers along the Wasatch Front, mid-century homes in Salt Lake, and rental properties across Ogden, Layton, and West Jordan. If you own one, you already know the truth: when these roofs fail, they tend to fail fast. Maybe you’ve spotted a new leak after a storm, soft spots underfoot, gravel piling up in the gutters, or ponding that never really dries out. Whatever brought you here, you’re probably wondering the same things most Utah homeowners ask us: Can my tar and gravel roof be repaired, how much will it cost in 2026, and how do I know when it’s finally time to replace it?
This guide answers all of it—clearly, practically, and with real Utah numbers.
We’ll break down how tar and gravel roofs work, the specific ways Utah’s extreme UV and freeze–thaw cycles shorten their lifespan, and the exact signs that tell you whether a repair will buy you time or if a replacement is the smarter investment. You’ll also see 2026 repair and replacement costs, comparisons to alternatives like TPO and metal, and how tools like the roof cost calculator Utah, asphalt shingles cost, metal roof cost Utah, and our roof replacement price guide fit into your decision.
Let’s help you figure out your best next step—before the damage gets worse.
Table of Contents:
- What You Should Know about a Tar and Gravel Roof in 2026
- How is a gravel and Tarred Roof Constructed
- How Long does a Tar and Gravel Roof Last?
- The 2026 “Repair vs Replace” Decision Tool
- 2026 Tar & Gravel Roof Repair Options
- Full Replacement Options
- Best Times for Repair Work
- Alternatives to Tar and Gravel Roofs
- Tar and Gravel Roof Removal
- Get Residential Roofing and Roof Inspections
What Utah Homeowners Should Know About Tar & Gravel Roofs in 2026
If you own an older flat or low-slope home along the Wasatch Front, there’s a good chance you’re living under a tar and gravel roof—even if your home listing simply said “flat roof.” Tar and gravel, also known as built-up roofing (BUR), was the standard system for Utah homes built from the 1950s through the early 2000s. It was durable, affordable, and handled foot traffic better than early membrane systems.
Nationally, most roofing experts estimate a tar and gravel roof lasts 20–30 years with consistent maintenance, though performance varies widely in harsher climates. In Utah, homeowners can see drastically different outcomes: some roofs experience major leaks after only 12–15 years, while well-maintained roofs may stretch 30+ years.
One reason aging is unpredictable is that damage often happens below the gravel layer. Once moisture enters one weak point, it can migrate laterally between plies. This is why many homeowners searching for tar and gravel roof repair Utah services do so after multiple “mystery leaks,” not after the first drip.
The real question in 2026 isn’t just “Is tar and gravel good?” It’s:
- How far along is my roof in its lifespan?
- Is a repair going to buy meaningful time?
- Would I save money long-term by switching to TPO or another modern system?
This guide helps you answer those questions with Utah-specific insights and clear cost expectations.
Types of Gravel and Tarred Roofs
A tar and gravel roof is made of multiple protective layers, each performing a specific role. Typically, the assembly includes:
- Roof deck and insulation
- Several plies (layers) of roofing felt or fiberglass, each embedded in hot asphalt
- A flood coat of asphalt
- A protective layer of gravel to shield the asphalt from UV and impact
These built-up roofing layers (asphalt, felt, gravel) create a thick, redundant membrane. The upside: durability, UV resistance, and good impact protection. The downside: locating leaks is difficult, because water can travel through the layers before emerging indoors.
When performing repairs, contractors often:
- Sweep or vacuum gravel away
- Cut into suspect areas
- Probe down to find trapped moisture
- Patch or rebuild plies
- Apply new asphalt and re-embed fresh gravel
This is why built-up roof repair cost Utah estimates can vary significantly once crews begin opening the roof. The system is rugged but labor-intensive to diagnose and repair.
A lesser-known factor is the original installer’s craftsmanship. Older Utah homes may have been built with widely varying ply counts and asphalt quality. As a result, two roofs installed in the same year can age completely differently. Moisture scans and core samples often reveal the truth faster than age alone.
How Long Does a Tar and Gravel Roof Last in Utah's Climate?
On paper, tar and gravel roofs can last 20–30 years, and in mild climates, some last longer. Utah’s climate, however, is uniquely harsh. Your roof endures:
- Intense high-altitude UV radiation
- Frequent freeze–thaw cycles
- Heavy snow loads followed by rapid melt
- High winds that can move gravel and expose asphalt
Because of this, the realistic tar and gravel roof lifespan in Utah tends to fall into these ranges:
- 12–18 years — Poor drainage or minimal maintenance
- 18–25 years — Average roofs with periodic patching
- 25–30+ years — Well-maintained roofs with resurfacing or coatings
Coating manufacturers report that applying silicone or elastomeric coatings can add 10–20 additional years to an aging tar and gravel roof—if the underlying structure is sound.
Regional differences also matter:
- Northern Utah (Ogden–Logan): More snow and longer freeze–thaw seasons
- Salt Lake / Wasatch Front: The worst UV exposure, leading to alligatoring
- Southern Utah: Extreme heat ages asphalt quickly but ponding is less common
Your attic insulation can accelerate aging too. Poorly insulated homes radiate heat upward, effectively “cooking” the roof from below—something many homeowners never consider.
Signs Your Tar & Gravel Roof Needs Repair
Most homeowners begin researching tar and gravel flat roof problems Utah homeowners face after seeing interior symptoms like:
- New ceiling stains
- Peeling paint or bubbling drywall
- Damp smells after storms
On the roof surface, warning signs include:
- Bald spots where gravel has worn or blown away
- Alligator cracking in asphalt
- Soft, spongy areas indicating trapped moisture
- Blisters or raised sections
- Ponding water remaining 48+ hours after moisture
Because water can migrate sideways under the gravel, the leak you see indoors rarely aligns with the defect outside. This makes professional inspection important. A roofer may vacuum gravel, cut into plies, and use moisture meters to track water spread.
A pattern we see often: homeowners apply DIY patches for years until a sudden ceiling collapse reveals long-term saturation. Early intervention usually costs far less than waiting.
Taking photos after storms is surprisingly effective. Comparing season-by-season lets you see ponding patterns, crack growth, and gravel movement before they turn into expensive issues.
The 2026 “Repair vs Replace” Decision Tool

Aging tar and gravel roofs don’t follow a simple countdown timer.
The smarter decision model for Utah homeowners includes four key factors:
- Roof age (under 15 often repairable; over 20–25 years worth evaluating replacement)
- Leak frequency (single vs multiple recurring leaks)
- Percentage of saturated area (>20–25% typically means replacement is more cost-effective)
- Condition of insulation and decking
As a rule of thumb: if your spending on repairs over 3–5 years approaches 25–35% of the cost of a new roof, replacement offers a better long-term return.
Some homeowners choose an intermediate option—such as coatings—to extend the roof’s life while planning for a longer-term upgrade. Others prefer switching to TPO sooner because it improves energy performance and eliminates the gravel-related maintenance burden entirely.
Ultimately, the right choice balances your roof’s condition with your appetite for risk and future repair costs.
If you’re noting leaks in a property you’re looking to buy, make sure it’s looked over by a Utah building inspector, preferably one with expertise in bitumen roofing systems. They will inform you of whether the roofing membrane can be patched up or whether more long-term work will have to be performed.
2026 Tar & Gravel Roof Repair Options (Utah Pricing Included)
Utah homeowners typically have four categories of repair options, each with different price levels:
1. Small Patch Repairs
These fix local problems like blisters, cracks, or small bare spots. Crews remove gravel, dry the area, install new plies, and re-embed fresh gravel. Costs generally range from a few hundred dollars into the low thousands, depending on roof access and severity.
2. Moderate or Large Area Repairs
Sections around drains, edges, or sagging points may require more extensive cut-outs and rebuilds. Labor is the dominant cost, often running $150–$300 per square (100 sq. ft.) in Utah, depending on complexity.
3. Full Resurfacing / Re-Graveling
Ideal when the base layers are still sound. This process renews the top asphalt and gravel layer, significantly improving UV protection and extending life.
4. Coating Systems
Silicone or elastomeric coatings applied over cleaned or partially stripped surfaces can add 10–20 years to the roof. They’re often the most cost-effective way to bridge the gap between repair and full replacement.
These also integrate naturally into comparisons generated by the
roof cost calculator Utah.
Full Replacement Options (and 2026 Utah Pricing)
When repairs are no longer cost-effective, homeowners usually compare three main replacement options: rebuilding a tar and gravel roof, upgrading to TPO, or selecting a premium membrane like PVC. Each option performs differently in Utah’s unique climate.
Option 1: Reinstalling a Traditional Tar & Gravel System
Although less common today, a full tear-off and rebuild is still possible. A traditional tar and gravel replacement involves stripping away all layers down to the deck, making necessary structural repairs, then rebuilding the multi-ply BUR system.
Pros
- Outstanding durability when done well
- Strong resistance to foot traffic
- Excellent puncture resistance
Cons
- Heavier than modern membranes
- Can hide leaks between layers
- Installation requires specialized crews and hot asphalt
2026 Cost Range
Traditional BUR replacements in Utah typically fall between $6.00–$9.50 per sq. ft., depending on access, tear-off complexity, and ply count. Larger homes or roofs with significant structural repair can exceed that range. Compared to other systems, BUR remains labor-heavy and costlier long-term because maintenance often involves gravel removal and re-embedding.
Option 2: TPO Membrane Conversion (Most Popular Today)
TPO is now the most common flat-roof replacement for Utah homes. It’s reflective, lightweight, and provides a continuous, seamless membrane that eliminates many of the traditional failure points of tar and gravel roofs.
Pros
- Excellent UV resistance—ideal for the Wasatch Front
- Reflective surface lowers cooling costs
- Welded seams prevent water intrusion
- Easier to inspect and maintain
Cons
- Requires skilled installers
- Can be punctured by sharp debris if walked on excessively
2026 Cost Range
Most Utah homeowners see $4.50–$8.50 per sq. ft., with white 60-mil TPO being the standard recommendation. TPO usually offers the best balance of performance and price, especially for homes facing high UV exposure.
Option 3: PVC or Modified Bitumen
PVC and modified bitumen are premium solutions often used for more demanding commercial or residential applications.
PVC Pros
- Excellent chemical and fire resistance
- Heat-welded seams similar to TPO
- Superior longevity in high-heat environments
Modified Bitumen Pros
- Thicker, durable surface
- Better flexibility in freeze–thaw cycles
2026 Cost Range
PVC sits around $7.50–$11.00 per sq. ft., while modified bitumen is typically $5.50–$9.00 per sq. ft. Pricing varies by thickness, color, and installation complexity.
When homeowners compare these options through your
roof replacement price guide, TPO often becomes the standout choice for value and longevity.
Best Times for Repair Work

Proper maintenance is essential to ensure the longevity and performance of a tar and gravel roof. By implementing a regular maintenance routine, property owners can identify and address potential issues before they escalate into more significant problems. Here are some key steps to effectively maintain a tar and gravel roof:
1. Regular Inspections: Conduct routine inspections of the tar and gravel roof to identify any signs of damage, wear, or deterioration. Inspect the surface, seams, flashings, and drainage systems. Look for cracks, blisters, loose gravel, or areas where the bitumen may be exposed.
2. Clear Debris: Regularly remove debris, such as leaves, branches, and dirt, from the gravel surface. Debris can accumulate and block drainage paths, leading to water pooling and potential roof damage.
3. Address Ponding Water: Pay attention to areas where water may accumulate or pond on the roof's surface. Prolonged ponding can weaken the roofing materials and lead to leaks. Ensure proper drainage by clearing any blockages in gutters, downspouts, and scuppers.
4. Repair Cracks and Blisters: Promptly repair any cracks, blisters, or punctures in the roof's surface to prevent water infiltration. Clean the damaged area, apply a suitable patching material or sealant, and ensure proper adhesion to the existing roof layers.
5. Maintain Flashings and Edge Details: Inspect and maintain flashings and edge details, such as those around chimneys, vents, skylights, and parapet walls. Ensure they are properly sealed and free from gaps or damage that could allow water penetration.
6. Trim Vegetation: Trim any overhanging tree branches near the roof to prevent them from rubbing against the surface, damaging the roof membrane, or blocking drainage paths. Ensure that vegetation does not accumulate on the roof.
7. Professional Maintenance: Consider hiring a professional roofing contractor experienced in tar and gravel roofs for regular maintenance inspections and repairs. They have the expertise to identify potential issues and perform necessary repairs or maintenance tasks effectively. Remember, safety is paramount when performing roof maintenance. If you are uncomfortable or unsure about any maintenance tasks, it is best to consult with a professional roofing contractor.
8. Document Maintenance History: Keep a record of all maintenance activities performed on the tar and gravel roof. This documentation helps track the roof's condition, identify recurring issues, and provide valuable information for future inspections or repairs.
9. Upgrade or replace trouble spots: High-quality flashing and compression drains can make your entire roofing installation more durable. To make your roof last longer, you can also have it strengthened or built up by layering the roof with more fiberglass or foam. This will improve its insulating properties.
10.
Consider a Coating: You can also opt for the application of an acrylic or elastomeric coating, which will make your installation more resistant to harsh weather conditions. You can also switch to a thermoplastic membrane, which will prevent moisture from infiltrating the layers between the asphalt and the roof base.
Alternatives to Tar and Gravel Roofs

While tar and gravel roofs have their advantages, there are several alternative roofing systems that property owners can consider. Here are three popular alternatives: TPO roofing, metal roofing, and Duro-Last roofing.
1. TPO Roofing (Thermoplastic Olefin):
TPO roofing is a single-ply roofing membrane made of a blend of rubber and plastic. It has gained popularity in recent years due to its energy efficiency, durability, and ease of installation. Some key benefits of TPO roofing include:
- Energy Efficiency: TPO roofs are highly reflective, helping to reduce heat absorption and lower cooling costs. They can contribute to energy savings and provide a more comfortable indoor environment.
- Durability: TPO roofs are resistant to UV rays, ozone, and chemical exposure. They have excellent weathering capabilities and can withstand extreme temperature fluctuations without significant degradation.
- Installation: TPO roofing is relatively lightweight and easy to install, reducing labor costs and installation time. It is available in various widths and can be mechanically fastened, fully adhered, or ballasted during installation.

2. Metal Roofing:
Metal roofing is a versatile and durable option that offers a unique aesthetic appeal. It is available in various materials, including steel, aluminum, and copper. Metal roofing has several advantages:
- Longevity: Metal roofs are known for their exceptional longevity, often lasting 50 years or more with proper maintenance. They are resistant to fire, rot, and insect damage.
- Energy Efficiency: Metal roofs can reflect solar heat, reducing cooling costs in hot climates. They can also be installed with insulation to enhance energy efficiency.
- Versatility: Metal roofs come in a wide range of styles, colors, and profiles, allowing for customization to match the architectural style of the building. They can be installed on both steep-slope and low-slope roofs.

3. Duro-Last Roofing:
Duro-Last roofing is a single-ply, thermoplastic roofing membrane that is prefabricated in a factory-controlled environment. It offers several advantages for commercial and industrial buildings:
- Custom Fabrication: Duro-Last roofs are custom fabricated to fit the specific dimensions of the building, reducing on-site labor and installation time. This precision manufacturing ensures a high-quality and watertight roofing system.
- Durability: Duro-Last roofs are highly resistant to punctures, chemicals, and UV radiation. They have a long lifespan and require minimal maintenance.
- Energy Efficiency: Duro-Last roofs have high reflectivity and emissivity, reducing heat absorption and lowering cooling costs. They can contribute to LEED certification and energy savings.
- Seamless Installation: Duro-Last roofs are installed using heat-welded seams, creating a seamless and watertight barrier. This eliminates the risk of leaks and enhances the overall performance of the roofing system.
When choosing an alternative to tar and gravel roofs, it is essential to consider factors such as the building's structural requirements, climate conditions, budget, and aesthetic preferences. Consulting with a professional roofing contractor can help determine the most suitable roofing system for a specific project.
Get Residential Roofing & Roof Inspections in Utah Today
Tar and gravel roofs have protected Utah homes for decades, and when maintained, they can provide years of dependable performance. But as these systems age—especially under the intense sun and freeze–thaw cycles of our state—the line between “a simple repair” and “time to replace” gets harder to read.
The most important thing to understand is that your roof’s condition matters more than its age alone. A 17-year-old roof with good drainage and only one trouble spot may be worth repairing. A 25-year-old roof with widespread saturation or recurring leaks is usually a better candidate for replacement—often with a modern membrane like TPO.
Costs matter too. Small repairs can extend service life, but repeated visits often add up quickly. Tools like the roof cost calculator Utah and our roof replacement price guide make it simple to compare repair vs. replacement using real, local numbers.
If you’re noticing leaks, soft spots, gravel loss, or anything that doesn’t feel right, don’t wait. Early intervention almost always saves money. We inspect tar and gravel roofs across the Wasatch Front every year and can give you a clear, straightforward assessment of your roof’s condition and your best next step.
Ready for answers?
Schedule a flat-roof inspection today—we’ll help you protect your home and budget with confidence.
The post Tar and Gravel Roof Repair – Everything You Should Know appeared first on Bob Harvey Roofing .














